Garage Guys Insurance

About GarageGuys: Number One In Vehicle Services Insurance

We are members in good standing with the following professional associations
Many of our employees hold professional designations and actively participate in advanced insurance educational programs.


Click for a closer look
Each month, we give away
10 Authentic GarageGuys shirts
Win a Shirt!

GarageGuys vs. the “Other Guys”:
Why doing business with us is always the right move!

GarageGuys is  dedicated solely to the insurance needs of the vehicle services industry. If you fix, fuel, sell or maintain vehicles, we are your experts. We are independent of any and all insurance carriers, associations or affiliations (although we are endorsed by many) and represent a wide variety of carriers and programs.  If you are ready to stop reading and get going, click here for our exclusive free offer worth $248.00.

Or call 800-762-1784 (8:00am to 6:00pm EST) and  speak to a GarageGuys insurance counselor at extension 202.

Our staff has over 100 combined years of insuring garages and service stations and we insure over 1000 separate facilities! 

Our practice is to maintain as many programs as possible for your benefit because one size definitely does NOT fit all when it comes to insurance. 

When you request an estimate from us, we will try to provide you with at least two options —  and more, when available.  Giving you a choice distinguishes us from those "other guys".

Our long list of satisfied clients and the industry associations we represent or are endorsed by is your guarantee of satisfaction with the way we do business!

Thank you,
Keith, Cristina, Peter, Eric, Tony and the staff at GarageGuys

GarageGuys Advantages

  1.  Currently representing 9 different programs for the auto trades including garage, repair, parts and sales.
  2. Currently have 2 EXCLUSIVE (available nowhere else!) programs specific to the auto trades.
  3. Combined 100 years of garage and auto experience
  4. Legal and claims help ON STAFF at no charge to clients
  5. Completely familiar with all franchise and lease requirements
  6. We have EVERY type of insurance you want but will sell you only what you need


2001 Marcus Avenue, Suite W180
Lake Success, NY 11042
 800-762-1784 or 516-358-3500 

Acrisure Agency Partner (logo)