Garage Guys Insurance

Service Station and Convenience Store (C-Store) Insurance Programs

Gasoline Filling and Service Stations including convenience stores, distributors, repair, car wash and all other automotive related businesses.
Call 800-762-1784to quote or bind insurance.
Speak with Pete at extension 209 or Eric at extension 230

Our GAS STATION/C-STORE PROGRAMS have no competition! You won't find better coverage for less money anywhere.

Whether you own a single gas station or are an MSO with 100 c-stores and related businesses, GarageGuys is your one-stop shop for insurance. In fact, if you own, lease or operate more than 10 locations, click here to explore an innovative and practical method of insuring your business. Or, if you are ready to stop reading and get going, click here for our exclusive free offer.

Most brokers have a one size fits all approach to insurance for gas stations and c-stores. GarageGuys has every insurance program your current broker has. But GarageGuys also has our own exclusive programs which can be tailored specifically to YOUR needs.  Need liquor liability?  Want crime insurance? Can't seem to get the pollution insurance policy you need? We've got everything you need in every size and from every quality carrier.

Tired of insurance audits and "extra" charges? Our programs are guaranteed cost — which means that the premium we quote is the premium you pay without any "adjustments" after the policy expires.

If you need us to handle your insurance administration for MSO's, we can do that for you too. For larger operators, we can design and implement fixed cost programs so that  you know in advance the actual cost of insurance at any location--making administration and cost-accounting simple. If you lease out some of your locations, we can design a master policy so that YOU can control the insurance (and costs) rather than relying upon out-dated certificates of insurance and mystery carriers provided by your lessees.

If you are a GarageGuys client, our legal department will help you craft risk transfer arrangements (including review of your current leases and contracts) in order to minimize your insurance and legal exposures where appropriate.

And unlike many "garage insurance" agents, we are not tied to a single insurance company. We can access the right program for you and get the exact insurance you need at a price that will surprise you.

Can we insure it?  You bet we can!
  • Gasoline Stations (24 Hour?  No problem!)
  • Convenience Stores (with or without gasoline sales)
  • No-audit programs available
  • Repair Shops (Including transmission, brakes, mufflers)
  • Crime Insurance (Including cash robbery and employee dishonesty)
  • Customer's Cars Coverage (GKLL)
  • Bonds including lottery, liquor and construction
  • Underground Storage Tank Coverage
  • Pollution Clean-up (including off premises)
  • Liquor Legal Liability
  • Health, Workers Comp and Accident
  • Auto, Tow and Tanker policies
  • Umbrella limits to $100,000,000 available.
  • See our complete menu of available coverages here
GarageGuys has 9 carriers writing insurance for this class
Insurance Carrier ratings: A to A++
Number of Programs available is: 14
Average savings range to current market conditions: 21% to 34%




2001 Marcus Avenue, Suite W180
Lake Success, NY 11042
 800-762-1784 or 516-358-3500 

Acrisure Agency Partner (logo)