Garage Guys Insurance

Buy Insurance Confidently from GarageGuys

We are the preferred property
and casualty insurance provider
We insure many of the largest MSO's and franchise locations
in our area.
We represent nearly 1,000 individual garages and service stations.
Many of our insurance carrier partners deal with us for the
auto trades and no one else.



You are dealing with the largest and most financially stable insurance companies in America as well as some of the most respected trade associations in the Northeast. Call 800-762-1784to quote or bind insurance. Speak with Pete (ext. 209) or Eric (ext. 230) for quick and reliable service.

CNA Insurance CompaniesWe like to be known by the company we keep.  That's why we are proud to be recommended and endorsed by so many of our industry and client partners. The products we sell are generally rated   "A" by AM Best.  Financial integrity is our watchword. When a particular type of insurance is available only from a lesser rated carrier, we will make sure you are aware of the carrier rating so that you can make an informed decision.

The GarageGuys Guarantee
The premium we quote you (so long as we have accurate information) is the premium you pay. Period.

But you don't need to take our word for it... Our reputation for professionalism and integrity is unmatched and we invite you to ask one of our many industry partners or clients about us.

Can we insure it?  You bet we can!

If you "fix, fuel, repair, service or sell" automobiles, trucks or just about anything with wheels on it, GarageGuys has the right insurance for you!

  • No-audit programs available
  • Repair Shops of all types (including transmission, brakes, mufflers, customizers, speed shops and others)
  • Salvage and Auto Parts Yards
  • Gasoline, Convenience including alternative energy
  • Distributors, MSOs and chains of all kinds
  • Crime Insurance (including cash robbery and employee dishonesty)
  • Customer's Cars Coverage (GKLL)
  • Underground Storage Tank Coverage
  • Pollution Clean-up (including off-premises)
  • Liquor Legal Liability
  • Health, Workers Comp and Accident
  • Auto, Tow and Tanker policies
  • Umbrella limits to $100,000,000 available
  • See our complete menu of available coverages here!

2001 Marcus Avenue, Suite W180
Lake Success, NY 11042
 800-762-1784 or 516-358-3500 

Acrisure Agency Partner (logo)