Garage Guys Insurance

Customer Service & Claims


If you would like us to assume the servicing of your current insurance policy, please review our Agent/Broker of Record Change Procedures and call us at 800-762-1784with any questions.
Tips for being prepared in case you do experience a loss:
Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA)
 To report a claim, locate the company your policy is placed with and report the claim via the phone number shown below. If your carrier does not have a number listed scroll down for claim forms that can be submitted online.
Phone Number
AIG 800-242-2418
Century Surety Fax 614-895-7040
CNA 877-262-2727
Hanover 800-628-0250
Harleysville 800-892-8877
Hartford 800-553-1710
Lancer 516-349-8888
Travelers 800-387-8734
Tower/Preserver 212-655-2000
Utica National 800-274-1914 x2772
If your company is not listed above or you would prefer to consult with us about the claim, please complete the appropriate claim form below.
ACORD ViewerBefore you can fill out these claim forms, you must install the ACORD Viewer.

To download to your machine, click on the image at the right.  When the File Download window appears, select Run and follow the directions as they are presented on screen. 

If you need help, please call us at 800-762-1784 or 516-358-3500.  We can also send you these forms as PDF files, however, you cannot save or email completed PDF forms with the full version of Adobe Acrobat.  The free Adobe Reader software will only allow you to fill out the form and print it.


2001 Marcus Avenue #W180, Lake Success, NY 11042-2061
 800-762-1784or 516-358-3500

Acrisure Agency Partner (logo)